Evaluating The Efficacy Of The G7's Price Cap On Russian Oil

The G7's price cap on Russian oil: One year later, effectiveness and compliance challenges emerge.

How effective is the G7's price cap on Russian oil?

The G7's price cap policy on Russian crude, marking its first anniversary, was established to maintain Russian oil in the global market while limiting Moscow's war-funding capabilities. This strategic move aimed to restructure the oil market and impair Russia financially without escalating global crude prices, a goal many experts deemed challenging.

Initial Effects And Shifting Market Dynamics

Initially, the policy led to a significant drop in Russian crude prices, as exports were rerouted to fewer buyers, primarily in India and China. This shift increased these buyers' negotiating power, resulting in Urals crude trading significantly below global benchmarks. However, the average export price for Russian crude has since rebounded, exceeding $80 per barrel in recent months, according to the Kyiv School of Economics (KSE).

Economist Benjamin Hilgenstock from the KSE notes that while energy sanctions impacted Russian economic stability initially, their effectiveness has waned, exacerbated by widespread violations of the price cap.

Russia’s War Economy Leaves Businesses Starved Of Labor
Russia’s military and armament production draw workers, creating civilian sector labor shortages and economic instability.

The Challenge Of Enforcement And Compliance

Despite the surge in Russian crude prices above the cap, US officials maintain the policy's success in its first year. They argue it has constrained Russia's selling price and imposed additional costs on Moscow by necessitating investment in an independent fleet and longer shipping routes.

However, for the policy's continued relevance, enforcement must be strengthened. The KSE suggests increasing attestation process oversight, ensuring adequate insurance for vessels at critical geographical points, and considering secondary sanctions against non-compliant entities.

Future Directions And Considerations

The US acknowledges the need for more stringent policy enforcement. Assistant Secretary of State Geoffrey Pyatt emphasizes the importance of targeting the "shadow fleet" and enhancing information demands from shippers. Recent US sanctions against companies breaching the cap signal a move towards tougher enforcement.

The success of Russia's shadow fleet in circumventing sanctions poses a challenge, but opportunities remain for the G7 to leverage their influence over a significant portion of Russian oil exports still tied to their jurisdictions.

As the US approaches its presidential election, balancing the need to tighten the price cap mechanism against the imperative to avoid global price hikes remains crucial. The G7's strategy will likely focus on increasing pressure on Asian ports and buyers, while navigating the complexities of a changing global oil market.

Subscribe to our newsletter and follow us on X/Twitter.

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.

Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.

You've successfully subscribed to REX Wire.

Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.

Success! Your billing info has been updated.

Your billing was not updated.